Preference vs. Usability: Are You Asking the Right Questions?

Last year, while mentoring a junior researcher, I observed a usability study of a health appointment scheduling app. She was eager to gather feedback, so she began by asking users which homepage layout they preferred—a minimalist version with just icons, or a more detailed version featuring shortcuts, tips, and upcoming appointments. Most users said they preferred the minimalist interface, calling it “clean” and “uncluttered.”

Yet, during actual use, the story flipped completely. Users who chose the minimalist home struggled to locate essential features. They missed new appointment alerts, struggled with navigation, and overlooked important actions like confirming visits. In fact, tracking session replays showed that navigation errors doubled in the minimalist version, leading to a 37% higher task abandonment rate (VWO, 2025). Although the users felt positive about the “look,” their performance and satisfaction plummeted—one participant even said, “I thought I'd like it, but I keep getting lost.”

This scenario drove home a crucial lesson: preference may win the “beauty contest,” but it rarely predicts what helps people succeed. Without measuring actual usability, we risk building products that look great, but frustrate or lose users the moment they need to get something done.

Watching this unfold reminded me how easy it is for well-meaning researchers to confuse what people like with what they can actually use. Mentoring that junior researcher was a wake-up call: it's tempting to ask about preferences because those answers are quick and feel positive. But building a great product isn’t about stacking up compliments—it’s about making sure it truly works.

This article explores the critical difference between user preference and usability. We will look at why we so often mix them up, how to ask better questions, and why focusing on function is the surest path to building user trust and loyalty.

The Great Mix-Up: Why We Confuse "Like" with "Works"

Preference is subjective. It’s a gut feeling, an aesthetic choice, or a personal bias. It’s when a user says, “I love this font,” or “This color scheme is ugly.” While this feedback has its place, it doesn’t tell you if the design is effective.

Usability, on the other hand, is a measure of effectiveness. It answers objective questions:

• Can the user achieve their goal?

• How quickly and efficiently can they do it?

• How many errors do they make along the way?

• Are they satisfied with the process?

Chasing preferences leads you down a rabbit hole of endless tweaks based on subjective opinions. You might end up with a product that everyone "likes" the look of, but no one can actually use. This is more than just a minor inconvenience; it has a direct impact on business success. According to VWO, 88% of online consumers are less likely to return to a site after a bad user experience, and 38% will stop engaging with a website if the content or layout is unattractive. This means that poor usability and confusing layouts can drive users away, no matter how much they like the aesthetic. A pretty design that fails its function is still a failure.

From "Do You Like It?" to "Did It Work?"

The key to unlocking real insights is to shift the questions you ask. Instead of focusing on aesthetics, focus on tasks and outcomes.

Good usability questions are about action. They are open-ended and prompt users to show you, not just tell you.

Instead of asking: "What do you think of this layout?"
Try asking: "Where would you click first to find your account settings?"

Instead of asking: "Do you prefer this icon or that one?"
Try asking: "Can you show me how you would add this item to your cart?"

Instead of asking: "Do you like the color of this button?"
Try asking: "Were you able to successfully complete your purchase?"

When you observe a user’s behavior, you gather objective data. Watching someone fail to complete a task three times is a far more powerful insight than hearing them say they prefer the color blue. Their actions reveal the friction points and usability hurdles that subjective feedback would never uncover. Investing in this process pays dividends. According to Harvard Business Review, improving the user experience to increase customer retention by just 5% can lead to a profit boost of 25% to 95%. That return on investment comes from solving functional problems, not from winning a beauty contest.

Building Trust Through Functionality

When a product works seamlessly, it builds trust. Users develop confidence not just in the digital tool, but in the company behind it. They know they can rely on your product to do what it promises, without frustration or confusion. This reliability is the foundation of customer loyalty.

Think about a well-designed banking app. You don't care if the buttons are your favorite shade of purple. You care that you can deposit a check, transfer money, and check your balance securely and without a single headache. The app’s boring, functional design earns your trust far more than a flashy but confusing interface ever could.

Conversely, a product that is difficult to use erodes trust. It sends a message that the company doesn't understand or respect its users' time and goals. Each dead end, confusing instruction, or failed task is a small betrayal. Over time, these frustrations accumulate and drive users away for good.

Conclusion: Stop Chasing Likes, Start Solving Problems

The debate between preference and usability ultimately comes down to your goal. Are you trying to create something that looks nice in a portfolio, or are you trying to build a product that people can depend on?

While aesthetics matter, they must serve functionality, not overshadow it. The most beautiful design in the world is useless if it prevents someone from achieving their goal. As designers, developers, and product managers, our responsibility is to be the user's advocate. This means looking past their stated preferences to understand their underlying needs.

Stop asking for opinions and start observing behavior. Measure success not in compliments, but in completed tasks. By prioritizing usability, you will create experiences that are not only effective and efficient but also build lasting trust with the people who matter most: your users.

#EveTheInsightsDiviner
#UsabilityTesting
#UserExperience